Moen 1200 vs 1222 vs 1225 Faucet Cartridge: Which One Do You Need?

Moen 1200, 1222 and 1225 faucet cartridges shown side by side

Disclosure: Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links, which can provide compensation to me at no cost to you. You can read our affiliate disclosure in our privacy policy.

In this article
  1. Moen 1200 vs 1222 vs 1225: Key Differences
  2. What the Three Cartridges Have in Common
  3. Moen 1200 Faucet Cartridge
  4. Moen 1200
  5. Moen 1222 Faucet Cartridge
  6. Moen 1222
  7. Moen 1225 Faucet Cartridge
  8. Moen 1225
  9. How to Tell Which Cartridge You Need
  10. How to Replace a Moen 1200 or 1225 Cartridge
  11. Frequently Asked Questions

A Moen faucet that drips, runs only hot or will not shut off usually needs a new cartridge. The trouble is that Moen makes several that look alike, and the 1200, 1222 and 1225 are the ones people mix up most. Some are interchangeable and some are not. Here is how to tell them apart and buy the right one on the first trip.

Quick answer

Watch how your handle works: if it only rotates to turn on and set the temperature, you need a Moen 1222; if you pull it out first, then rotate, you need a 1225 (or a 1200 on older faucets). The 1222 is for Posi-Temp tubs and showers, while the 1200 and 1225 are for one-handle kitchen and bathroom faucets.

Key takeaways

  1. Different handle action: the 1222 turns only; the 1200 and 1225 pull to open and turn for temperature.
  2. Volume control: the 1200 and 1225 let you control the flow, the 1222 does not.
  3. 1200 is full brass: made for older faucets built before 2002.
  4. 1225 is the updated 1200: plastic case with a brass piston, for faucets made after 2002.
  5. 1222 is for Posi-Temp: the 1200 and 1225 do not work in Posi-Temp valves.

Moen 1200 vs 1222 vs 1225: Key Differences

The main difference is how a faucet fitted with each cartridge is operated. A faucet with a Moen 1222 adjusts the water temperature only by rotating the handle. A faucet with a Moen 1225 or 1200 turns on when you pull the handle out, and then you rotate it to set the temperature.

The 1200 and the 1225 do the same job. The only difference is the build: the 1200 is made entirely of brass, both the case and the piston, while the 1225, its updated version, has a plastic case and a brass piston.

CartridgeHandle actionVolume controlBuildBest forPrice
Moen 1200Pull, then rotateYesFull brassOne-handle faucets made before 2002 (Moentrol)Check Price
Moen 1222Rotate onlyNoBrass and plasticPosi-Temp tub and shower valvesCheck Price
Moen 1225Pull, then rotateYesPlastic case, brass pistonOne-handle kitchen and bath faucets made after 2002Check Price

What the Three Cartridges Have in Common

Despite their differences, all three are efficient, high-quality Moen cartridges. They work in single-handle fittings, they last a long time in a modern home, and each one is a straightforward swap once you know which you need. Replacing the cartridge is also far cheaper than replacing the whole faucet.

Moen 1200 Faucet Cartridge

Moen 1200 faucet cartridge being inserted into a faucet
Inserting a Moen 1200 cartridge.

If you have an older Moen faucet in your kitchen or bathroom, the 1200 is usually the one to get. It is a quick, easy replacement for Moen one-handle bathroom and kitchen faucets, and it gives you smooth control of both temperature and flow.

It is built entirely of durable brass. It is the right choice for most older single-handle Moentrol valves, the ones without automatic pressure balancing, but not for Posi-Temp valves.

Moen 1200 one-handle kitchen and bathroom faucet cartridge replacement, brass

Moen 1200

Best for older faucets

Check Price on Amazon

Pros

  • Made entirely of brass
  • Controls the water volume
  • The most durable of the three

Cons

  • Does not work with Posi-Temp valves
  • Harder to remove and replace, especially when an old brass cartridge is stuck

Moen 1222 Faucet Cartridge

New Moen 1222 faucet cartridge ready to replace an old one
A new Moen 1222 cartridge.

The Moen 1222 is the replacement for Moen one-handle Posi-Temp tub and shower faucets, in both tub/shower and shower-only setups. It is designed specifically for these valves, so it fits right every time. It is made of brass and plastic.

Installation is simple and the results last. If your shower handle only turns and never pulls out, this is almost certainly your cartridge.

Moen 1222 one-handle Posi-Temp faucet cartridge replacement for tub and shower

Moen 1222

Best for Posi-Temp showers

Check Price on Amazon

Pros

  • Works with Posi-Temp valves
  • Simple to replace

Cons

  • No water volume control

Moen 1225 Faucet Cartridge

A genuine Moen 1225 faucet cartridge
A genuine Moen 1225, marked MOEN on the body.

The 1225 is the upgraded version of the 1200. It fits Moen one-handle bathroom and kitchen faucets, but not Posi-Temp or ExactTemp valves. Its brass piston handles the wear, and the easy installation makes it a quick job.

Make sure you get the genuine OEM part. A real Moen 1225 has the word "MOEN" marked on the cartridge surface. A fresh cartridge is one of the most common fixes for a single-handle faucet that has started to leak.

Moen 1225 one-handle kitchen and bathroom faucet cartridge replacement kit

Moen 1225

Best for most kitchen and bath faucets

Check Price on Amazon

Pros

  • Controls the water volume
  • Fits almost every Moen one-handle kitchen and bath faucet
  • Replaces the older 1200

Cons

  • The plastic case can break if forced
  • Not for Posi-Temp or ExactTemp valves

How to Tell Which Cartridge You Need

  1. Check the paperwork

    If you still have the faucet's documentation, it names the cartridge. That is the most reliable answer.

  2. Watch the handle

    If you only rotate the handle (usually counterclockwise) to turn the water on, you need a 1222. If you pull the handle out first, you need a 1225 or a 1200.

  3. Consider the age of the faucet

    Pull-out faucets made before 2002 used the brass 1200. Faucets made after 2002 use the 1225.

  4. Bring the old cartridge to the store

    Once it is out, compare it side by side with the new one. Length, ears and stem should match.

How to Replace a Moen 1200 or 1225 Cartridge

Replacing a 1200 or 1225 is a short job, and Moen publishes a step-by-step tutorial. Here is the short version.

Safety first

Turn off the hot and cold supply valves under the sink, then open the faucet to release the pressure. Put a towel or a plug in the drain so small parts cannot fall in.

  1. Remove the handle

    Pry off the cap and remove the handle screw, then lift the handle and the parts above the cartridge off the faucet.

  2. Pull the retaining clip

    The brass U-shaped clip holds the cartridge in place. Pull it straight out with pliers.

  3. Remove the old cartridge

    Grip the stem with pliers and pull it straight up. If it is stuck, use a Moen cartridge puller rather than twisting hard.

  4. Install the new cartridge

    Push it in with the stem in the same position as the old one, then refit the clip.

  5. Reassemble and test

    Put the handle back, turn the water on and check hot, cold and the off position.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is the best option for the kitchen/bathroom faucet?

The Moen 1225 or 1200 is best for one-handle kitchen and bathroom faucets, and the 1222 for Posi-Temp showers and tubs. When replacing, match the old cartridge: if the handle only rotates, you need a 1222; if you pull it out first, you need a 1225 or 1200.

What's the difference between the Moen 1222, 1222b, and 1222HD?

They share the same design and operation. The 1222B is the same cartridge packaged and sold in bulk, and the 1222HD is a heavy-duty version made for commercial use.

Is Moen 12801 the same as 1225?

Yes. The Moen 12801 and the 1225 are treated as the same cartridge, with only a negligible difference, so they can be used as replacements for each other.

How to replace a Moen 1200 or 1225 cartridge?

Shut off the water, remove the handle, pull the retaining clip, pull out the old cartridge and push in the new one in the same position. Moen has a step-by-step tutorial on its website.

The Moen 1200, 1222 and 1225 each have their own job. For one-handle kitchen and bathroom faucets, choose the 1225, or the 1200 on faucets made before 2002. For Posi-Temp tubs and showers, choose the 1222. If you are unsure, check how the handle moves: rotate only means 1222, pull then rotate means 1225 or 1200.