Moen 1224 vs 1224B vs 1248: Which Moen Cartridge Do You Need?
Disclosure: Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links, which can provide compensation to me at no cost to you. You can read our affiliate disclosure in our privacy policy.
In this article
A dripping two-handle faucet, a handle that turns too far or a Roman tub that fills slowly: in most Moen fixtures, the fix is a new cartridge. The trouble is that the Moen 1224, 1224B and 1248 look a lot alike. Here is how they differ and which one your faucet needs.
Quick answer
Pick the Moen 1224 or 1224B for Moen two-handle kitchen, bathroom and tub/shower faucets, and the Moen 1248 for a two-handle Roman tub faucet. Between the 1224 and the 1224B, the difference is how the handle stops, so match the one that came out of your faucet.
In my experience as a plumber, most "bad cartridge" calls end with the wrong part in the box. The cartridge is cheap; the second trip to the store is what costs you. So before you order, pull the old one or find your faucet model number.
Key takeaways
- 1224 and 1224B: replacement cartridges for Moen two-handle faucets, including 2- and 3-handle tub and shower valves.
- 1248: a high-flow two-handle cartridge made for Roman tub faucets, such as the Moen 4999 valve.
- Handle stop: the 1224B stops the handle at 180 degrees, while the 1224 turns freely and relies on the faucet's own stop.
- Fit first: check your faucet model before you buy; a wrong cartridge leaks or will not seat.
- DIY job: swapping a Moen cartridge takes basic tools and usually less than an hour.
Moen 1224 vs 1224B vs 1248 at a Glance
| Cartridge | Fits | Handle travel | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moen 1224 | Moen two-handle faucets, 2- and 3-handle tub/shower valves | Turns freely; for faucets with their own stop | Check Price |
| Moen 1224B | Moen two-handle faucets | Built-in stop at 180 degrees | Check Price |
| Moen 1248 | Two-handle Roman tub faucets (4999 valve) | High-flow, turns in either direction | Check Price |

What a Faucet Cartridge Does
A cartridge is the valve inside the faucet body. When you turn the handle, you turn the cartridge stem, which opens or closes the path for the water. On a two-handle faucet, there is one cartridge under each handle: one for hot, one for cold.
When a cartridge wears out, you see it right away. The spout drips after you close the handle, the handle gets stiff or loose, or the flow drops. Low flow is not always the cartridge, though. A clogged aerator is the more common cause, so unscrew the aerator and rinse it before you take the faucet apart.
The Three Cartridges in Detail
The 1224 is the standard replacement cartridge for Moen two-handle faucets. It is also used in 2- and 3-handle tub and shower valves, which makes it one of the Moen parts I keep on the truck.
It has a solid brass body with a protective coating against corrosion, which matters if you have hard water. The stem turns freely, so it is meant for faucets that already have their own handle stop. I recommend it for Moen faucets only: on another brand, even a cartridge that seems to fit can leak.
- Type
- Two-handle replacement cartridge
- Body
- Brass, corrosion-resistant coating
- Fits
- Moen two-handle faucets, 2- and 3-handle tub/shower valves
- Handle travel
- Free-turning
Pros
- Brass body resists corrosion and hard water
- Fits most Moen two-handle faucets
- Also used in Moen 2- and 3-handle tub and shower valves
- Genuine Moen part
Cons
- Not a reliable fit for non-Moen faucets
The 1224B looks identical to the 1224, and that is where people go wrong. The difference is the stop: the 1224B stops the handle after it turns 180 degrees, while the 1224 keeps turning.
That built-in stop makes the 1224B the right choice for faucets that have no stop of their own, where the handle would otherwise spin all the way around. It works on both hot and cold sides and has the same corrosion-resistant coating as the 1224.
- Type
- Two-handle replacement cartridge
- Handle travel
- Built-in stop at 180 degrees
- Use
- Hot or cold side
- Coating
- Anti-corrosion
Pros
- Built-in stop keeps the handle from over-rotating
- Works on hot and cold sides
- Coating helps prevent corrosion
Cons
- Wrong choice if your faucet already has its own stop
The 1248 is a two-handle, high-flow cartridge built for Roman tub faucets, where the handles sit on the tub deck. It fits the Moen 4999 Roman tub valve. Like the others, it has a brass body with an anti-corrosion coating.
Why not put a 1224 in a Roman tub? Because a tub needs volume. A sink faucet limits the flow at the aerator, but a tub spout is built to fill a large tub fast, so the valve itself has to pass more water. The 1248 also turns 360 degrees in either direction, so it can be fitted on either side of the deck. Check your valve number with Amazon's Confirm Fit tool before you order.
- Type
- Two-handle high-flow cartridge
- Fits
- Roman tub faucets, Moen 4999 valve
- Body
- Brass, anti-corrosion coating
- Rotation
- 360 degrees, either direction
Pros
- Solid brass body
- High flow for filling a tub
- Turns 360 degrees in either direction
- Fits most Moen two-handle Roman tub faucets
Cons
- Access under a tub deck can be tight, so some people call a plumber
How to Choose the Right Moen Cartridge
Sink or tub/shower faucet
Moen 1224 or 1224B
For a two-handle kitchen, bathroom or tub/shower faucet. Take the 1224 if the faucet has its own handle stop, the 1224B if it does not. The safest way to tell is the number on the old cartridge.
Deck-mounted tub faucet
Moen 1248
For a two-handle Roman tub faucet on the Moen 4999 valve. It passes more water than a sink cartridge, so the tub fills at a normal speed.
How to Replace a Moen Two-Handle Cartridge
- Phillips screwdriver
- Allen (hex) wrench
- Adjustable wrench or pliers
- Moen cartridge puller (for stuck cartridges)
- Silicone faucet grease
- A rag to plug the drain
- Shut off the water
Close the shut-off valves under the sink, or the main supply for a tub. Open the faucet to release the pressure and drain the lines.
- Remove the handle
Plug the drain so no small part falls in. Pop off the handle cap, then remove the screw or set screw with a screwdriver or Allen wrench and lift the handle off.
- Unscrew the retaining nut
Loosen the nut that holds the cartridge with an adjustable wrench or pliers. Wrap the jaws with a rag so you do not scratch the finish.
- Pull the old cartridge
Note how it sits before you pull it. If it will not come out, use a cartridge puller rather than prying.
- Install the new cartridge
Grease the O-rings lightly with silicone grease, then push the new cartridge in with the same orientation as the old one.
- Reassemble and test
Refit the nut and handle, open the water slowly and check that the handle turns the right way and nothing drips.

Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Buying by photo: the 1224 and 1224B look the same. Go by part number.
- Skipping the grease: dry O-rings tear on the way in and leak from day one.
- Forcing a stuck cartridge: prying can damage the faucet body. A puller costs less than a new faucet.
- Forgetting the aerator: if the problem was low flow, clean the aerator too, or the new cartridge will not fix it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is my Moen faucet leaking after replacing the cartridge?
Usually the cartridge is the wrong model, it is not fully seated, or an O-ring was pinched or left dry. Pull it, check the part number and orientation, grease the O-rings with silicone grease and reinstall it. If a genuine part still leaks, contact Moen about the warranty.
How do you get a stuck Moen 1224 cartridge out?
Shut off the water, remove the handle and retaining nut, then use a Moen cartridge puller. Mineral buildup from hard water is what makes old cartridges stick. A penetrating spray such as WD-40 can help loosen it, but the puller does the real work.
How do you change a Moen 1224B cartridge?
Shut off the water, remove the handle, unscrew the retaining nut, pull the old cartridge, insert the new one in the same orientation, then refit the nut and handle and test. The step-by-step guide above covers each stage.
How long does a Moen cartridge last?
It depends on your water and how often the faucet is used. Hard water and debris shorten its life. Replace it when the handle gets stiff, the faucet drips or the flow drops even with a clean aerator.
How do I know which Moen faucet cartridge I need?
Find your faucet model number (on the paperwork, the box or Moen's website), then check it against the cartridge's compatibility list. Amazon's Confirm Fit tool on the product page does the same check. When in doubt, take the old cartridge to the store and match it.
For a Moen two-handle sink or tub/shower faucet, choose the 1224 if the faucet has its own handle stop and the 1224B if it does not. For a Roman tub, take the 1248. Check the part number on the old cartridge, grease the O-rings, and the swap is a quick job.
Sources


