Badger 5 Vs Badger 500 Vs Badger 5XL: Any Difference?

Last Updated: August 26, 2022 | By JULIAN GILL

Do you want to purchase a garbage disposal for your new home? Or are you looking to get a new one? InSinkErator has some of the best-selling products on the market, including the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL. In this piece, we’ll look at the difference between all three, which is virtually nothing. That’s right, the only difference between the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL is the name stickers on each and their prices. Still not convinced? Check out the table below for a breakdown of the three garbage disposals and their specifications.

Table of Contents:

InSinkErator Garbage Disposal Badger 5 Vs Badger 500 Vs Badger 5XL
InSinkErator Garbage Disposal Badger 5 Vs Badger 500 Vs Badger 5XL
SpecificationBadger 5Badger 500Badger 5XL
Motor Power½ HP½ HP½ HP
Motor TypeDura-Drive Induction motorDura-Drive Induction motorDura-Drive Induction motor
Grinding Speed (RPM)172517251725
Feed TypeContinuous FeedContinuous FeedContinuous Feed
Dimension in inches (Height X Width)11.5  X 6.312511.5  X 6.312511.5  X 6.3125
Noise InsulationQuietQuietQuiet
Grinding Chamber capacity26 Oz26 Oz26 Oz
ConstructionGalvanized SteelGalvanized SteelGalvanized Steel
Power CordOptional, additional costOptional, additional costOptional, additional cost
Reset ButtonFittedFittedFitted
Warranty3-year in-home service3-year in-home service3-year in-home service

Key Differences Between Badger 5, Badger 500, And Badger 5XL

As shown in the table, the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL have identical specifications and no discernible differences in features or appearance. The only difference is the price, with the 500 and 5XL being more expensive.

However, the Badger 500 and 5XL are not available on the InSinkErator website because the Badger 500 is designed for Home Depot and the 5XL is designed for Lowe’s. Also, the first Badger 500s were a few inches longer than the Badger 5, but they’re now the same length.

Specifications and Features Compared to Badger 5, 500, And 5XL


The most important feature of licensed garbage disposal is how well it grinds ‘garbage disposal friendly’ solid food waste. The Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL perform admirably in this regard. They have a ½ HP induction motor that runs at 1725RPM. This is admittedly slow in comparison to some other products, but induction motors perform best at low speeds, so it balances out.

Noise Insulation

Because they are low-cost items, none of the three garbage disposals have designated noise insulation features, but they are relatively quiet due to the induction motors used. The Badger 500 is slightly louder than the other two, but the difference is insignificant.

Feed Type

A garbage disposal can be of the batch or continuous feed variety. A continuous feed garbage disposal grinds waste as you feed it, as opposed to a batch feed garbage disposal, which requires you to feed waste in batches. The Badger 5, 500, and 5XL are all continuous, which is preferable—and more convenient—and can hold up to 26 oz of waste at a time. However, because they are continuous feed, the capacity of the grinding chamber is unimportant.

Reset Button

A garbage disposal’s reset button is a convenient feature. It enables you to restore the entire unit if it jams or becomes clogged. Most garbage disposals, as well as these three, have this button. On the Badger 5, 500, and 5XL, the reset button is red and located on the bottom of the equipment. InSinkErator also includes a ¼-inch wrenchette, which you will use to clear the debris before pressing the reset button. To avoid clogging, run your garbage disposal with cold water on a regular basis to help wash out any particles that may clog it.


Nothing lasts forever. Not even garbage disposals. You’d have to do some electrical repairs on it at some point. On Badge 5, 500, and 5XL, InSinkErator offers a 3-year in-home service and repair-only warranty. That is, if your equipment develops a fault during this time, they will send one of their 1500 technicians around the world to repair it at no extra cost to you.

Check this for more:

Conclusion: Which one is the best choice for your kitchen sink?

We recommend that you purchase the Badger 5. With over 12K Amazon reviews compared to just over 300 for the 500 and 5XL, it is clearly the most popular and thus tested and trusted. Furthermore, because the Badger 500 and 5XL are only slightly more expensive with no significant upgrades, it is best to go with the less expensive option. Finally, if you act as if you don’t know they’re all the same and are convincing enough, you can get the 500 and 5XL for the same price as the Badger 5. In any case, they’re all the same.


Is Badger 1 the same as Badger 1XL?

Yes. Just like the Badger 5 and its remodels, the Badger 1 and Badger 1XL are the same product with regards to specifications and features, with the only difference being their respective prices. 

How long does the Badger InSinkErator last?

A Badger InSinkErator, like other garbage disposals, should last 10 to 15 years if used and maintained properly, after which they begin to clog more frequently. However, as the equipment wears, you may notice cracks or leaks even before the life expectancy. When this happens, it is best to replace it because repairing it would be too stressful.

You might also like:

author of julian gill pictureJulian Gill

Julian Gill is a mechanical engineer and Certified in Plumbing Design (CPD) and worked as a plumbing engineer for ten years. Besides this, he is interested in home improvement and currently works as a writer. @JulianGillPro

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. And That is a very small commission from purchases made via the links at no additional costs to you. Learn more.

Leave a Comment